Lower Your Click Through Rate To Achieve Better Performance
Topics: clearsaleing, sem, seo, ppc, pay per click, search engine marketing, search engine optimization
Since the beginning of search engine marketing, search engines have been training their users to focus on achieving a higher click through rate (CTR). The search engines say that an ad with a higher CTR is more ‘relevant’ and more ‘compelling’ to searchers, thus it will ‘perform’ better. Read below to see exactly how the Top 3 search engines speak to this:
MSN: The relevance of your ads affects their performance. Making your ads highly relevant is an inexpensive way to improve their position and increase their CTR.
Yahoo: An ad’s quality index is primarily determined by its CTR. To improve your quality index, focus on making your ads as compelling as possible, so that users will be more likely to click on them, giving you the best possible CTR.
Google: Over time, our system determines which ad is performing better based on higher historic CTRs and Quality Scores compared to other ads within the ad group. Based on this data, we’ll show your higher performing ads more often.
The search engines are not saying anything wrong here, however, they define performance differently than most search engine marketers would. The search engines equate performance with CTRs, whereas a search engine marketer would define performance as ROI. So, that brings up the question, “Do ads with higher CTRs earn a better ROI?”
At ClearSaleing, we decided to find out. To answer this question, we used our advertising tracking technology across several clients in different industries to measure the performance of an ad text in terms of total profit, total revenue, conversion rate, profit/order, revenue/order, profit/click, revenue/click and CTR. For the purpose of this test, we used Google since they are the only search engine that provides the option to rotate the distribution of your ad text, which makes sure each ad runs an equal number of times.
We allowed each ad text to run for a long enough period to gather a statistically sound sample of impressions before we began to measure its performance. Of all the metrics ClearSaleing captured, we focused our attention on the most important metric to our client’s search marketing; profit. At the end of the day, we want to run the ad texts that generate the most total profit for our clients, regardless of what the other metrics might tell us to do.
After the testing period was complete, we analyzed the data. We stack-ranked each ad text within each ad group according to several metrics, including CTR, profit, etc. We found that there is no statistical evidence that proves the ad text with the highest CTR is the ad text that produces the most profit. In many cases, we found the most profitable ad text to be the ad with the lowest CTR. The results of the study led us to conclude across all clients that judging ad text performance based on CTR is not an indicator of an ads true performance, as is common belief in search marketing.
Our study did not try to answer the question, “How could ads with higher CTRs produce less profit than ads with lower CTRs?” To answer this, we would need to employ a consumer behavior specialist and even then, our answers would be subjective at best. Nonetheless, we did try to put some sense around how the language we use in ads affects the ad’s performance. Here is an example of 3 different ad texts used for a client in the musical instrument space and our thoughts on how the language dictated the ad’s performance (note: we changed the client’s name to hide their identity):
Ad A: According to the search engines, this ad would be our most “compelling” because it had the highest CTR. This ad had the broadest focus and an attractive call-to-action without any conditions. We found that we sold a lot of low end accessories from this ad, with most of the orders coming in at under $100. This ad also had the lowest average order size of the three. Because of this ad’s focus on low price and free shipping, it seemed to bring in the most cost-conscious consumers.
Ad B: This ad was more targeted by focusing on the two top-selling guitar manufacturers. These two manufacturers sell some of the more expensive guitars in the market. Therefore, users that clicked on this ad might be more serious musicians and, more importantly, looking to spend more money because they want guitars instead of accessories. The free shipping offer is attractive, but unlike the first ad, it got the buyer thinking bigger purchase. We did sell more guitars from this ad text than we did in ad A.
Ad C: This ad had a definitive qualifier. It basically told searchers that if what you want is not over $99, you are probably better off shopping elsewhere. Therefore, the people that did click this ad were more serious buyers, which was proven by the fact that the average order value was higher than the other ads, as was the conversion rate. Overall, this was the most profitable ad even though it had the lowest CTR and least “compelling” message.
For each client that was involved in this study and each of our clients since, we have turned our focus from trying to achieve higher CTRs to trying to earn more profit from each ad text, and in the process, we have often found the ad text we selected is not always the ad text with the highest CTR, therefore, in essence, we have lowered our client’s CTRs on average to achieve better performance in terms of the only metric that matters; profit.
Adam is the Chief Revenue Office at ClearSaleing. He is a seasoned sales manager starting insides sales teams at Google and Actuate Software. Adam holds a B.S.B.A. in Marketing from The Ohio State University. www.clearsaleing.com
Previous Articles Highlighter:
How An Effective Internet Marketing Campaign Made Me Give Pay-Per-Click Advertising Another Chance (1)
After awhile, I got quite jaded with all the standard squeeze pages that beg me to cough up my prized e-mail address with their umpteenth free newsletter, outlandish claims of internet riches and a "last seat on the bus" mentality with either a "just 52 left at this price" or "you've got 1 hour, 12 minutes and 6 seconds to buy" (complete with a second-by-second ticker to try and stress me out).
Online Business Entrepreneur Talks About Linking And SEO (2)
When Google changed it's algorithm and decided to mainly rank sites according to link popularity this was the signal for lots of link farms to spring up and the reason for lots of emails in our inboxes asking for reciprocal links.
Chiropractic Marketing 101: Your Number One Most Valuable Chiropractic Asset (3)
On the other hand, your entire office space could burn to the ground (God forbid) and if you have a large herd of loyal patients you can still make money.
Do Freebies Generate Leads? (4)
A time limited offer for the sign-up for the freebie creates a sense of urgency in visitors, making them sign-up for it, and becoming leads. Another main benefit of offering a freebie is that one can take the temperature of the market, test if it is a hot market or not.
Can Internet Marketing Solutions Help Your Website Attract Customers? (5)
New marketing solutions are constantly being generated. Many businesses with a large internet presence are finding that they need to hire additional manpower just to cope with all the different devices and techniques.
EBusiness Solutions - Why Your Small Business Needs One (6)
Is adopting an eBusiness Solution worth the effort? Are the short term difficulties involved in making the transition to eBusiness worth the effort? In virtually all cases, Yes.
Lost Marketing Opportunities And How To Get Them Back (7)
Marketing is one of the most essential parts of running your successful business. 2. Marketing is the lifeline of your business and what keeps your cash flow healthy.
Drawing Up A Successful Small Business Marketing Plan (8)
shoe shops compete directly with other shoe shops. Your indirect competitors compete for the same budget in the same general area e.g. movie theatres compete with restaurant for family entertainment spending.
How To Become An Affiliate Marketing Superstar (9)
Don't look at the absolute top earner within an affiliate program and assume your earnings will be similar. Also keep a watchful eye at the length of commitment the program wants from you.
7 Proven Ways To Turbo Charge Your Traffic (10)
Once you identify your sites keywords, you need to optimize your site for those keywords. 5) Write Articles To Lead Traffic To Your Site Submit original articles to article directories to generate links to your site.
MLM Lead Capture Page - Why You Need Your Own Lead Capture Page (11)
Now, let's imagine the following scenario... You have just joined a reputable company, with a complete package. Great product, lucrative compensation plan, charismatic sponsor and last but not least...a "personalized" lead capture page customized with your photographs, contact details and affiliate links.
Good Marriage Of Marketing Techniques (12)
Not much feedback to go on there. Nothing nags at us as much as the knowledge that something is amiss but not knowing exactly what it is. The key to getting the desired response from your target audience is as much in what they want as in who they are.
Discover The Latest Advertising Marketing Technique (13)
At least it is not the preferred media. In fact why we advertise is that spreading by word of mouth is considered too slow. However, we know that word of mouth could be one of the most effective ways to promote a product or service.
Why Haven't You Got A List Yet? (14)
Its human nature: We all prefer to buy through personal recommendation than by enticing advertisements. And JVs, or cross-promotions are all about personal recommendation. The only thing is - as every super-affiliate knows - even if you are offering attractive commission rates, the site that is getting promoted always gets more out of the deal than the JV partner who is doing the promoting.
Is It Really Possible To Make Money Without A Website? (15)
Over time the cumulative effect of these articles - together with the number of programs you are promoting - will turn the initial trickle of affiliate payments into a river.
Three Tips For Successful Article Marketing (16)
However, you may not know exactly the power of it. You can build up your image as an expert in your industry by writing quality articles. In fact, it can be even more than just building up images.
Secret Method To Get Google AdWords At No Cost To You (17)
And no, nothing about his "secret" is illegal - nor does it require that you know someone on the "inside" at Google, Yahoo, MSN, Overture and others. Instead, the New Yorker boasts proudly "...this is something that I caught onto just before 2000 when there was so much search engine craze running around, and started doing small just to test things at first ...
Affiliate Marketing - Is It Worthwhile To Pursue? (18)
Thus if you have a unique idea for an ebook or software program then consider placing it on Clickbank and take advantage of the thousands of affiliates that can sell your products for you.
Moving Away From Pain: Moving Towards Pleasure (19)
Do your prospects take action to avoid pain or to pursue pleasure? When we know how to use both, we can be powerful communicators like Shaun motivating our clients and prospects to take action immediately - with no regrets.
Advantages Of Using Dream Weaver To Design Web Pages (20)
Having reviewed some of the evidence for the case in favour of undertaking Dream Weaver training, it only remains for you to make the final verdict. Author is a freelance copywriter.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
Using E-zine Advertising To Generate Tons Of Laser Targeted Free Traffic (1)
They have built reputations for being in touch with their readers needs and have proven that they can deliver timely information that their readers can actually use to solve their problems, meet their needs, make them look better or feel better, and answer their questions.
How To Optimize A PDF For SEO (2)
If you target the correct market long tail topics and keywords, you should be able to generate decent traffic to the deeper pages in your website. Russell (aka "the keyword guy") is a search engine optimization auditor and co-inventor of the Theme Zoom keyword research tool.
Website Promotion In A Box (3)
3. Implement the long term traffic systems instead of basing your whole online business on paid advertising. While PPC ads, ezine advertising and other paid web site promotion techniques work, don't forget that they will promote your site only for as long as you pay.
How To Succeed With Your Email Subscriber List - Love Your Subscribers (4)
Your profit increases and this may also mean you have more resources to benefit your subscribers. For example, you can spend a portion of your profit to create a product that will help your subscribers.
How To Write Your Own Information Product (5)
3. How do I preserve them to last over the years? 4. How should they be cleaned? 5. How can I start a floral arrangement business?
Organic Traffic Ways To Get Your Share (6)
I know website owners that write and submit fifteen to twenty articles a month. Just imagine the links pointing back to your site and the search engines will reward you with an ever increasing share of organic traffic relevant to your website.
Generate Leads Through Traffic Exchanges (7)
This is referred to by most marketers as the subscribers list. This particular program or service is vital to the triumph of an ad campaign. - A One Time Offer - Also known as an OTO is used with the above mentioned autoresponder to present the subscriber with a special discount on a part of the product's extras or may even offer the product itself at a bargain discounted price.
Five Useful Tips For Web Designing (8)
3) Have a easy and clear navigation You have to give a easy and very straightforward navigation menu so that even a young child will know how to use it.
Sponsoring Downline: Ride The Internet Highway To MLM Success (9)
Lubano Lim is a Netpreneur with a passion for helping others succeed. For a very limited time, discover the secret system used by many ordinary people to generate thousands of prospects without calling anyone...
Work From Home MLM Business Opportunities - Automate Your Way To Success (10)
Don't you agree that most people use the internet to look for information? For example, someone using the internet may be trying to find more information about how to become a professional speaker.
How To Build Downline Fast In Any MLM Program (11)
There is a saying that if your downlines are able to earn a profit in their first 90 days, they are more likely to stay. Let us see what the fastest way to build a downline is.
Is Home Based Business Online Training Important (12)
You need to always make sure that any opportunity you choose to start has the step by step online training. Before starting your business you have to be trained on how to advertise the business and how to make your business successful.
Creating Internal Links On Your Website (13)
Summarize What You Have Written At the end of every week or month, you should publish a summary of all the articles that you have posted on your blog site.
Seo Contests, Are They Good For Link Building, Or Not (14)
It is being run by a UK based forum website and are tempting would be competitors with a $1,000 first prize. The structure is simple; you create a web page and place a link to their site.
Writing A Great Tutorial (15)
Just imagine that the reader has no idea what you are about to explain and tell it to them in a simple manner. Give them all the steps in a visual manner.
Do Not Listen To Every Piece Of SEO Advice (16)
They may even follow through on there promise and get you into the top 10 for your selected keywords. I must stress that there are only a handful of quality companies out there so be very vigilant if trying this method.
Getting Started In Affiliate Marketing (17)
Post free reports for visitors to download. Link to these in your signatures elsewhere and in your posts on your blog. Traffic You need to get people to visit your site.
All Affiliate Marketers Procrastinate (18)
The essence of this article is to have a plan. Plan what you do. Do what you plan. Record what you have done. For more affiliate marketing articles and tips, visit my blog at myworldofinfo.wordpress.com free to distribute this article in any form as long as you include this resource box.
Do You Splog Or Blog? - Affiliate Marketers With Wordpress Beware (19)
It's free, it's easy, and you can be up and running in minutes. However, an affiliate marketing blog on Wordpress.com can be shut down before you can say why.
How You Can Make A Great Domain Name (20)
When you start looking at different words that you could use, you may also want to remember that the fewer the words, the easier it will be to remember. You are trying to pick something that will not be easily forgotten.
Permalink to Lower Your Click Through Rate To Achieve Better Performance